Weekly Specials
Monday & Tuesday Pick-Up Special
Free Topping Wednesday
Daily Lunch Special
Every Monday and Tuesday, snag a LARGE CHEESE PIZZA for only $12.99! Add toppings for an extra $2/per.
Every Wednesday, get up to 3 FREE TOPPINGS on any Medium, Large or Gluten-Free Pizza.
Get 2 slices + 20 oz drink for only $9 every day. Slices are typically available until 4 pm daily.
More Deals...
Daily Double
TWO small, 1-Topping Pizzas - $18.99
TWO Medium, 1-Topping Pizzas - $26.99
TWO Large, 1-Topping Pizzas - $34.99
Party Specials
Hosting a Party? Let us handle the cooking. Get a 32-piece Sheet Pizza plus 2 or 3 Add-Ons - Wings, Chicken Fingers, Fries, Boneless Wings, Mozz Sticks, Breadsticks and more!
Add-On Deals
Get a Large Cheese Pizza + 12 Boneless Wings for only $30.99
Gates
3869 Lyell Rd.
Rochester, NY 14606
585-426-0270
8 Great Locations across Greater Rochester, NY
Find the shop closest to you
Fairport
1345 Fairport Rd.
Fairport, NY 14450
585-924-2660
West Greece
1169 N. Greece Rd.
Rochester, NY 14626
585-225-8630
Latta Road
3366 Latta Rd.
Rochester, NY 14612
585-225-0020
Hilton
7 Main St.
Hilton, NY 14469
585-392-9000
Ontario
1208 Route 104
Ontario, NY 14519
315-524-3000
Victor
99 E. Main St.
Victor, NY 14564
585-924-2660
Webster
2186 Empire Blvd.
Webster, NY 14580
585-787-3333
Crafting Authentic Pizza Moments
Mechanical engineer turned Pizzamaker, Tony Caraglio (pictured), opened his first shop in Hilton back in 2004. Now 22 years later, Tony owns 8 pizzerias across the Rochester area.
Caraglio's strives to bring the authentic, comforting flavors of the pizza Tony grew up loving, crafted with care and a commitment to making every guest feel like family. Our passion for quality, community, and exceptional service means you’ll always enjoy a delicious, memorable meal!
Eat, Earn, Redeem!
Caraglio's Rewards
FREE Medium Pizza
FREE Birthday Pizza
Earn Points
Exclusive Offers
Get a FREE medium cheese pizza added to your account after you spend $10.
Get a FREE small, one-topping pizza every year on your birthday.
Rewards Members earn 2 points for every $1 spent. Points can be redeemed for FREE food!
As a Rewards Member, you'll have access to exclusive, member-only deals and discounts.
What our customers are saying...
We had amazing pizza and wings! In fact, there was an error on the order and not only did they fix it right away but made us a priority! Going back for more!
Chad C.
Webster Location
Our go to place for pizza and wings! What's underrated is their fries! We always get pizza with wings and fries! Just thinking about it now makes me want to order all of that food! 😂 Do yourself a favor and order from there! Sign up for their rewards program and you earn points for free large pizzas and stuff!
Gates Location
Hun H.
We have been searching for a pizza place like we grew up with. And we have found it! Never going anywhere else again.
The pizza was fabulous, wings great and the prices very reasonable. My husband never says much but he was impressed!
Fairport Location
Lauren C.
FAQ